Petition against the implementation of a Ban on the Export of Scrap Metal from South Africa
Comments
#1
I run a business that employs 54 people, who will lose their incomes if the ban is implemented. Most of our employees are the sole bread winner in their household with a minimum of 4 direct dependents. Our company also services over 300 businesses that will also loose this legally generated income from the resale of their scrap generated through their businesses and waste collection. Our business only buys from registered businesses.Nancy Strachan (Durban, 2022-08-19)
#2
I disagree with the policy implementation towards banning scrap metal tradingElisha Naidoo (Durban, 2022-08-19)
#4
I am a disable person who relies on the income I earn of dealing in scrapmetalSeelan Govender (KZN , 2022-08-19)
#6
Dealing in scrap is my only incomeBrandon lee Keir (East london, 2022-08-19)
#7
I am signing because government hasn't fully consulted with all rolleplayers in the sector, more specifically the micro and small scrapyard. Taking the route they are currently taking will ensure a negative impact on the local economy and job (direct and indirect) lossesCheryl Naicker (Clairwood, 2022-08-19)
#8
I’m signing as I’m against this policyHitarth Shah (Gauteng , 2022-08-19)
#9
I am a legitimate scrap metal dealer and realise how this is going to affect the already impoverished people of our country and benefit the elite been fed by our governmentBrian Impson (Durban, 2022-08-19)
#10
I am a scrap metal dealer that wants to preserve the integrity of the scrap metal trade. The restrictions on the scrap metal trade are crippling the industry.Neville Seal (Johannesburg , 2022-08-19)
#11
beacause i do not agree with the new proposed regulationsSundisha Bipath (Durban, 2022-08-19)
#16
I’m signing because I am in support of the view points expressed by RASA - the Recycling Association of South Africa.Sonaly Kandhai (Pietermaritzburg, 2022-08-19)
#23
This is wrong to do, so many people will be unemployedMichelle Gates (Durban , 2022-08-19)
#28
This will not stop the theft as it is the smaller company buying it from the thievesPeter Alberts (Johannesburg, 2022-08-19)
#30
I make A living of recycling, and also provide a service to the people who pick cans of the street who also make a living.Niven Giani (Durban, 2022-08-19)
#31
Its destroying jobs in South Aftica. Absolutely counter productive and not well thoight through. Ridiculous to say the least.Kobus Van Graan (HEIDELBERG , 2022-08-19)
#32
I’m an effected partyDarryl Sigamoney (Durban, 2022-08-19)
#35
I am scrap metal business owner and I know this will cause major unemployment, financial lot of other issue does not make sense the rule that they want to implementFadiel Bowas (Cape Town , 2022-08-19)
#36
This directly effects me and my family,I will lose everything,including my home!Shaun Day (Durban, 2022-08-19)
#37
The ban will oppress the ability for local companies to compete, it will come at the cost of many jobs of people who are involved in the handling and trading of scrap metal.Darius Van Niekerk (Cape Town, 2022-08-19)
#39
I support thisCarol Klopper (East London, 2022-08-19)
#40
I employ 5 people with another 20 dependants that earn a living from recycling and it will create chaos and unemployment in their livesRiaan Oosthuizen (Gauteng, 2022-08-19)
#42
We are a Dealer and we do business the legitimate way! We have over 40 employees. 90% of our business is generated by informal traders and scrap collectors! We do not buy stolen metals!!!Juanita Outram (Bendor, 2022-08-19)
#43
Private business should not be punished for the inadequate system of the government. Licensed scrap yards are inspected every few weeks but we give details of illegal scrap yards to SAPS regularly but they dont even go to inspect them.Tertius Cloete (Cape Town, 2022-08-19)
#45
I'm a scrap dealer and against the ban of export of scrap. What happens to my staff and my family who relies o. My business as a scrap dealerUdash Naidoo (Durban, 2022-08-20)
#46
I'm am a Scrap dealer and I follow all the rules of the second hand the prices of Scrap Metal is very bad at the moment because of all what is happening I think youl should investigate properly and find the person that is buy illegal goodsMiranding Reddy (Durban, 2022-08-20)
#47
We work in the scrap metal and recycling business. We will end up losing over 40 employees who rely on us to feed their families. Over a 1000 waste pickers rely on us who sells their little bit of cans or scrap to us. This will let poverty go up sky high and crime will drastically increase.Janine Klopper (East London, 2022-08-20)
#49
I work in the scrap industry and it is my only source of income by the government implementing the ban it will close many companies . And what they are doing is illegal its price fixing and it will have a huge impact on the gdp of the country and the government will lose revenue. 90% of the bigger companies already have government ministers at the helm. So at the end of the day would it not be unfair that they are only enriching them selves and in turn taking the money out of the mouths of the public,who already have no income. It will also make unemployment triple in numbers . Futher crippling the already vulnerable enconomy of south africaLuke Pescivolo (Midvaal, 2022-08-20)
#51
Thousands will loose their jobs, streets will be lined with scrapNadine Burton (Durban, 2022-08-20)
#53
Millions of people will lose their jobs because of that south Africa doesn't need that we need to make jobs not make job lossesAllen Van Rensburg (East london , 2022-08-20)
#54
I own a scrap metal business Cougar ScrapKubendhran Moodley (Durban , 2022-08-20)
#55
The way in which the government is handling this is unethical and only aims to benefit the mills and foundries. We are already under stain due to the PPS system. Further restrictions will cripple the scrap industryKeith Richter (Durban, 2022-08-20)
#59
I have been working for a legitimate scrap dealer for 15years and I value my job.Richard Forster (Durban, 2022-08-21)
#60
I do not agree with the new regulations proposedMahesh Bipath (Durban, 2022-08-21)
#61
This ban will ultimately cause the loss of my livelihood.Elizabeth Gibbley (Durban, 2022-08-21)
#62
I'm signing this petition because it is illegal for government to take food from the mouths of hundreds of families struggling to survive this harsh environment that they do nothing to help South African but dig the hole deeper! Corruption and theft of the highest order.Eileen Hunter (East London, 2022-08-21)
#63
This is my income and will be on the street without the scrap industryCaroline Burton (Amanzimtoti, 2022-08-22)
#64
Regulating law abiding citizens via a scrap metal export ban will not address those responsible for illicit activities and the unintended consequences of such a blunt instrument do not appear to have been properly considered.Mike Wilson (Durban, 2022-08-22)
#65
It's a state capture on scrap..select fewWill make a fortune. On the expense of scrap Dealers..
James Roberts (Durban , 2022-08-22)
#66
State capture of scrap metal recyclingKim Marais (Pinetown, 2022-08-22)
#67
In an already struggling industry, you want to implement more restrictions than there already is.Registered scrap dealers already abide by the law and conduct legitimate business dealings. The problem is a crime issue and not a trade issue. It's impossible for all suppliers to apply for second hand goods license.
Montana De Beer (Richard's bay , 2022-08-22)
#68
This is a legitimate industry which many law abiding citizens/entrepreneurs rely on for a honest income to support their family.Jennifer Cooney (BEDFORD GARDENS, 2022-08-22)
#72
If the ban will be implemented I have no other option I must retrench at least 4 workers to compensate for the loss of incomejohan jacobs (klerksdorp, 2022-08-22)
#74
This bill is designed to protect vested interests at the expense of the many who would lose their income as a result of this law.PETER W H ELSMORE (KEMPTON PARK, 2022-08-22)
#76
I own a small scrapyard in Betulie Free State,and the people here are dependent on our bussisnes for an income to buy daily essentialsHeinrich Brown (Bloemfontein, 2022-08-22)
#79
We have a recycle business we have 15 employees , we do our work according the act. Who will provide for 15 families if this happens?Changtelle Hough (Springs, 2022-08-22)
#80
I’m signing because I work at a stainless steel and aluminum recycling company. The only mill in South Africa, Columbus is not buying scrap till next year sometime leaving us with the only option of export. With this ban the business can’t continue and many people will be left without jobs.Ashley Moss (Cape Town , 2022-08-22)
#81
I THINK THAAT THIS PROPOSED BAN WILL HAVE A VERY BIG IMPACT ON LIVELYHOODS AND UNEMPLOYMENT . I ALSO THINK THAT IF THE COPPER IS THE PROBLEM THEN ADDRESS THAT ISSUE AND LEAVE THE OTHER PRODUCTS THAT THERE IS NOT ENOUGH DEMAND FOR LOCALLY IN ORDER TO ENSURE FAIR TRADING WITH INTERNATIONAL MARKETS .RIKUS VAN DER WESTHUIZEN (STILFONTEIN, 2022-08-22)
#84
Scrap Metal dealers are being victimized by the government due to the inability of the security services to protect infrastructure, where the government is holding scrap Metal dealers ransom for their inability to police at the source.Rose Ashe (Pinetown, 2022-08-22)
#86
I and my company are against the implementation of a Ban on the Export of Scrap Metal from South AfricaMonique De Jager (Gauteng , 2022-08-22)
#87
I am working in the Matel IndustryMarius Van der merwe (Kuruman, 2022-08-22)
#88
I am against the implementation of a ban of the export of scrap metal from South Africa due to the consequences it may have on the recycling industry, the informal collectors, scrap generators and it’s employeesDonovan Trump (Johanessburg, 2022-08-22)
#89
Because I'm a Scrap Metal Traders since 1975 I don't buy copper but it will effect the people that bye legitimate copper from Electrisions, Plummer and armature winders the government says they must apply for a 2nd hand goods license it does not make sense that copper is legal but if this is not resolved it could put millions of people out of work, I do not condone the fact that people bye elegal copper if they are court take there trading license away and close them down,And further more all the Cash for Scrap must be closed down they don't have a trading license or pay tax like me and all ligetemet trader do so I say to the government don't close the export market as it will put millions out of work and I don't think South Africa can afford that.Glen Lincoln (JHB, 2022-08-22)
#93
I am against the implementation of a ban of the export of scrap metal from South Africa due to the consequences it may have on the recycling industry, the informal collectors, scrap generators and it’s employeesNicyta Wilcox (Germiston, 2022-08-22)
#94
I am against the implementation of a ban of the export of scrap metal from South Africa due to the consequences it may have on the recycling industry, the informal collectors, scrap generators and it’s employees.Danielle Kennedy (Hurlyvale, 2022-08-22)
#95
In my business at least 18 people will be without work.Cecil Doyle (Vryburg, 2022-08-22)
#98
My family owns a scrap metal recycling business and so many people are going to lose their jobs because of this ban.Tracy Moss (Cape Town, 2022-08-22)
#99
Banning the export of scrap is only treating the symptoms and not fixing the problem. The materials that we trade in has got no relation to the theft of infrastructure, yet we will also be affected by this. I suggest regular site inspections, especially of those yards that do not have the relevant documentation and procedures in place.This ban will result in thousands of families losing their only income which could also result in increased crime just to survive.
Frederik Coetzer (Johannesburg, 2022-08-22)
#101
Government making as they please. This can not be allowed. What will happen to all of us already strugling beacause government causes more poverty and job losses, and now this. Not everybody gets a fat paycheck for sitting around and doing nothing. Now government is really screwing people on street level poverty more over, even those who lost jobs and everything during covid pandemic. This is crazy, I really hope International news and media will hear our cry and see this corrupt, useless moaners in power, what they are doing to people of South Africa. More of their greed comes to light during stupid shit like this.Jacky Strydom (Vierfontein, 2022-08-22)
#108
I'm own a recycling bussiness and 8 family will be affectedAltus Yssel (Hoopstad, 2022-08-22)
#111
Scrap Metal DealerBrendon Muller (Bloemfontein, 2022-08-22)
#112
I'm signing because i work for a scrap yard and earn a salary from itMarianne De Necker (Christiana, 2022-08-22)
#113
Owning a company directly affected by these happenings together with all our employees who are dependent on the income they earn from scrap metal in order to provide for their familiesLeandre van den Heever ( Christiana , 2022-08-22)
#114
Scrap metal business owner affected by the current situation all my employees and clients are affected as scrap metal trading is their only source of incomeHardus Van den heever (Christiana, 2022-08-22)
#116
am against the implementation of a ban of the export of scrap metal from South Africa due to the consequences it may have on the recycling industry, the informal collectors, scrap generators and it’s employees.Nico Wiid (Germiston, 2022-08-22)
#119
I disagree with government policyGail Downing (North Riding, Johannesburg, 2022-08-22)
#122
This is unfair towards Scrap Metal DealersCorlia Laney (Bloemfontein, 2022-08-22)
#123
Will not change anything except for more povertyWillem Barnard (Odendaalsrus, 2022-08-22)
#128
seems like a only a view and the goverment are the only winners here, not even to mention job lossesRINA VERSTER (PRETORIA, 2022-08-22)
#131
Want vir van die mense is die skrape wat hule verkoop al inkomste wat hule het.en daar gan duisende mense werk verloor as die staat aan hou met hule planne wat nie gan werk nie.mense wat staat gemaak het op die skrap wat hule op tel en verkoop gan begin steel om vir hule gesinne te sorg.huisbrake gaan meer word!Petro Human (Vryburg, 2022-08-22)
#134
I am signing because i believe that this is going to make matters worse for the people depending on the money they get from selling legal scrap. And it is going to cause more job losses in our countryAdriana Human (Vryburg, 2022-08-22)
#136
I am a scrap metal dealer ,who have 11 full time workers ,and almost 50 000 registered clients on my system.Louis Stroebel (Bloemfontein , 2022-08-22)
#138
This could cause u huge lost of employment and also businesses to close down which will leave a lot of people unemployed. This again will have another impact in our country which will also lead to more looting and other problems. Also if they find that a certain product cause problems why not only put an temporary ban on that product instead of having everything blocked. I foresee more problems arising from this action than any good that could come from this. This needs to be revised as this is not a solution to the current problems. This will have an effect world wide.GERT JANSEN VAN VUUREN (KLERKSDORP, 2022-08-22)
#141
I am signing this petition as I am working for a scrap dealer because it affects all of us it affects us all and all the employees it will cost lost of people with no income the theft will get worse andChrissie Breedt (Vryburg, 2022-08-22)
#142
People are going to loose there job's and living costs is getting out of controalMarius van Heerden (Edenvale, 2022-08-22)
#143
We have families to take care of.Aswell as unemployed people who take care of their families for at least a bread a day.
NOT ALL dealers is corrupt
May God Bless you in this Descision NOT TO BAN scrap dealers🙌🙌🙌🙌
Cornelia Jooste (Klerksdorp, 2022-08-22)
#144
I am signing because the recycling industry is helping the environment and also job creationAbel Pool (George , 2022-08-22)
#147
I feel government is not doing enough to apprehend the culprits. Since the foreigners are happy go lucky in South AfricaToko Jason (Bloemfontein , 2022-08-22)
#148
In favour of keeping scrap metal companies open and many people to keep their jobs.Doret Du Toit (Klerksdorp, 2022-08-22)
#151
Im signing the petition lots of people will be without a job and theft will increaseMonique Human (Vryburg , 2022-08-22)
#152
I'm signing this petition because the proposed ban is complete and utter rubbish! It will affect the lives of those dependent on the export of scrap.Jenny Moss (Cape Town, 2022-08-22)
#153
I'm signing because scrap yard is helping us with money that we don't have... As for us as a young star we don't have job. Government is failing us so scrap yard is so helpful to us.. And I'm asking myself if the was no scrap yard what could we eat all this time.. I'm saying scrap yard bring help to all us if they don't see that is really a problem cause us we getting help from scrap yard. Thank you ❤️Virginia Mjandana (Taung , 2022-08-22)
#155
It won't help to stop everything,the goverment must improve on police and security at their companies ext.....not every one is buying steal goods time to catch those who doesHerman van Niekerk (Odendaalsrus, 2022-08-22)
#156
I'm against banning exporting of scrap metalHananje Stroebel (Bloemfontein , 2022-08-22)
#159
I believe this will have a massive impact on our economy and people of this country who have just come out of pandemicLara Morgan (Johannesburg , 2022-08-22)
#163
This is how I put food on the table for my kidsJenny-lee Lambrechts (Jhb, 2022-08-22)
#165
The recycling business keeps SA clean and if casual sellers can’t sell scrap they won’t have another way to make money and crime will thus increase!Marno De beer (Bloemfontein, 2022-08-22)
#169
No export ban is going to stop corruption in our country. It will only enrich a few selective companies and create a cartel.Costantino Airaga (Kempton Park , 2022-08-22)
#170
There's workers that will end up without work and families will suffer to provide for their and their childrens futureJonathan De Noon (Carletonville , 2022-08-22)
#171
I work at a Scrap yard in Kuruman. Many people are dependant on the little money they make from selling scrap in order too eat something that day.Danelle Roodt (Kuruman, 2022-08-22)
#177
Scrap metal recycle give a income to those who don’t receive a income. This is a good source off income to those who din”t have work in south africaLouret Jooste (Klerksdorp, 2022-08-22)
#179
Many people will be without jobs and income.We cannot afford more unemployed people. Government should rather implement proper strategies to curb criminality...
Terence Sinclair (Boksburg, 2022-08-22)
#181
This Ibdustry gives apeople with no jobs an income, recycling is for the good because the goverment doesnt even clean our streets or parks(non existend) so now why would you like to take the only money from people with no jobs who are cleaning up everything the goverment does not do....I am going to start a war against this really....and I will do it....let PEOPLE RECYCLE OTHERWISE SOUTH AFRICA IS JUST A BIGGER SHIT HOLE!!@Sandra Wessels (Orkney, 2022-08-22)
#182
Because it will affect too many lives that depend on it.Aloraine Snyman (Bojanala, 2022-08-22)
#184
My family depends on the scrap metal without this work we will struggleMmaletsatsi Tshandu (Bloemfontein, 2022-08-22)
#192
I'm signing this because I'm against of the proposed ban on scrap metal.How I'm going to support my family without a job.and this will just increase the crime in the country if people without jobs to support themselves.
Johannes Tembe (Johannesburg , 2022-08-22)
#198
The scrap industry is fital for many poor people who only live by the few rand they make daily by selling their scrap they collect. And by closing the scrap industry more people will lose their jobs in a already unemployd country. Our police service together with companies like Eskom and transnet should be more educated in what actually is illegal metals and our law sistem should be stricter against criminals.George Human (Vryburg, 2022-08-23)
#199
I am an employee of a Scrap metal and will be directly impactedRianda Van Rooyen (Bloemfontein, 2022-08-23)